3 different sizes of pizzas on the table

Best Pizza Myrtle Beach: Best Reviewed Pizza Places

In my life, I have not found any people who do not love Pizza. Everyone loves Pizza. I always try out the best local pizzas when I travel to new places. Last week, I was in Myrtle Beach for my summer vacation. I talked to locals about finding the best Pizza places in Myrtle Beach. I have tried most of Myrtle Beach’s Pizza to find the best Pizza at Myrtle Beach. Today, I will share my experience regarding the best Pizza in Myrtle Beach with all of you. Let’s explore the article.

This article contains affiliate links. We might get commissions from those links if somebody make full purchase. Please read Disclosure section for more information. 

Best Pizza in Myrtle Beach: Top Spots to Satisfy Your Cravings

Before starting the article, I want to tell you about Myrtle Beach. It is a tourist attraction, so summertime is usually busier than usual. It was crowded when I was there. If you like a quiet restaurant, you can go there around October to December. At that time, Myrtle Beach stores were usually slower than at other times of the year. Now, let’s explore our article to find out which Pizza is the best in Myrtle Beach.

Best Pizza Myrtle Beach

I will cover the best Pizza location, open hours, contact information, prices, and facilities here.

Mellow Mushroom

Mellow Mushroom Pizza is so delicious. You can enjoy their Pizza in 3 different locations in Myrtle Beach.

1. Myrtle Beach- Mellow Mushroom

Location: 1571 21st Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC, 29577

Open Hours: Mon-Thursday, Sunday- 11 am to 9 pm; Friday and Saturday- 11 am to 10 pm

Contact Information: (843) 444-1122

2. Murrells Inlet- Mellow Mushroom

Location: 3280 U.S. 17, Murrells Inlet, SC, 29576

Open Hours: Mon-Thursday, Sunday- 11 am to 9 pm; Friday and Saturday- 11 am to 10 pm

Contact Information: (843) 651-0909

3. North Myrtle Beach- Mellow Mushroom

Location: 1101 Highway 17 North, North Myrtle Beach, SC, 29582

Open Hours: Mon-Thursday, Sunday- 11 am to 9 pm; Friday and Saturday- 11 am to 10 pm

Contact Information: (843) 273-0595

Mellow Mushroom offers different categories of Pizza. Recently, they launched new pizzas for their 50th anniversary. Pizzas like Supper Pepp, the Marley, and Maui Wowie Honey Sriracha wings are included in this category. They also offer different categories of stone-baked pizzas. Those tastes are exceptional.

different type of salad menu at mellow mushroom pizza
Image Different Types of Mellow Mushroom foods Source Mellow Mushroom

I ordered a large custom chicken Pizza with mellow thin crust (60 calories) when I was there. I took oil and garlic (40 calories) as a base and added Mushroom, extra mozzarella (115 calories), pineapple, and black olives. If you like, you can add additional sauce. But I’m only fond of a few sauces, So I prefer light sauces. It is good to let you know that to add extra ingredients, you have to pay $3. Usually, large Pizza is $18, medium Pizza is $14.25, and small Pizza is $11.

Mellow Mushroom also offers gluten-free Pizza, including its 10-inch signature gluten-free pizza. In addition, it offers Burgers, Calzones, Hoagies, Wings, and Munchies. Most interestingly, it offers vegan Pizza for those who do not eat meat.

It would be best if you tried their vegan avocado hoagies. This one is delicious. In addition, Mellow Mushroom offers Tempeh Hoagies for veggie lovers, which are served with tomatoes, lettuce, and melted provolone cheese. Furthermore, they provide sweets and drinks for their customers. So, in my view, it is just a complete pizza package. You will get any Pizza you like. For more information, you can visit to Mellow Mushroom website.

Ultimate California Pizza

Like Mellow Mushroom, California Pizza has three different locations in Myrtle Beach. Let’s explore those locations, open hours, and contact information-

25th Avenue- Ultimate California Pizza

Location: 2500 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577

Open Hours: 11 am to 10 pm, everyday

Contact Information: 843-626-8900

Surfside- Ultimate California Pizza

Location: 1502 N Hwy 17, Surfside Beach, SC 29575

Open Hours: 11 am to 10 pm, everyday

Contact Information: 843-477-8282

Barefoot Landing- Ultimate California Pizza

Location: 4862 Hwy 17 S, North Myrtle Beach, SC 29582

Open Hours: 11 am to 10 pm, everyday

Contact Information: 843-361-8108

pasta, salad and subs menu
Image Different type of food at Ultimate California pizza Source Ultimate California Pizza

Ultimate California Pizza offers different categories of pizza. They provide signature pizza, custom build pizza, special pizza.

Signature Pizza: Under Signature Pizza, they provide homemade Italian, Gluten Pizza, and thin and crispy cauliflower. Usually, Gluten Pizza is 10-inch, and you have to pay an extra $4 for this Pizza. Price varies from $12 to $20 depending on which toppings you want.

Custom-Build Pizza: I built my own custom pizza when I visited the Ultimate California Pizza store. They have three different types of Pizza: small—$11, medium—$15, and large—$17. If you want more toppings, you have to pay extra money. They offer two different kinds of toppings: regular and premium. Regular Toppings Price: P: .99¢ M: 1.98 L: 2.48; Premium Toppings Price: P: 1.39 M: 2.38 L: 2.78.

Special Pizza: Ultimate California Pizza offers special Pizza on special occasions like Christmas, Thanksgiving, and Labor Day. They also offer a Wednesday special package. If you buy one special pizza, you will get the other one 50% off. I took this offer when I visited there. Also, they provide only $25 for two large pizzas on Wednesday. For more information, please visit Ultimate California Pizza website.

Also, they offer chicken salad, house salad ($4.99), oven-roasted chicken salad ($13.49), and Malibu Greek Salad ($10.49). All of those salads are delicious. If you have a kid, they also have a package for them. Usually, kids package $9, including breaded white meat chicken chunks served with celery, chips, or applesauce. Furthermore, they make Personal and Cheese Pizza, and a Dilla (palm bread folded and stuffed with cheese and served with applesauce) for the kids.

Toffino’s Italian Bakery Deli Pizzeria

Location: 550 Farrow Pkwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577


Open Hours: Tuesday to Saturday- 11 am to 9 pm

Contact Information: (843) 477-1598

Price per person: $10-$20 per person

For more information, please visit to Toffino’s pizza website.

pizza on the table
Image Pizza at Toffinos Source Toffinos pizza

Toffino’s Pizza sells almost everything, including the best delicious Pizza, pasta, salad, sandwiches, and starters. Let’s talk about those items and prices.

STARTERS AND SALADS

Besides pizza, Toffino’s starters include calamari, mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, meatball sliders as well as a meatball app alongside caprese salad. If you want half a pan of 50 mozzarella sticks, that will run you $55; half a pan of fried ravioli will run you $60. Anyone in your family can conveniently share it with you.

I tried two types of salads from Toffino’s Pizza- garden salad and grilled chicken salad.

Garden Salad: Contains lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, sweet peppers, and carrots. It is priced between $30 to $50.

Grilled Chicken: The Main ingredients are American cheese and grilled chicken. The price varies from $40 to $70. I love grilled chicken salad a lot.

Chef Salad: A mixture of ham, turkey, Swiss, and boiled egg served with garden salad. The price is $40 to $70.

SANDWICHES

They have hot and steak sandwiches. Usually, sandwiches cost $8.5 to $12, but you will get the taste of real sandwiches from here.

COLD HOAGIES

Almost all hoagies are made of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and sweet peppers. Toffino’s offers different types of hoagies, such as capicola, roast beef, chicken salad, tuna, turkey with cheese, and many others.

PIZZA

Tofino is well known for its Pizza. They offer different kinds of Pizza, such as special Pizza, calzones (half filled with mozzarella and ricotta), and build-your-own Pizza. Pizza sizes are 12 inch and 16 inch.
If you are vegetarian then, you can prepare your veggie Pizza with some fresh tomatoes, peppers, mushroom, onion & olives along with basil & bell pepper.

PASTA

They serve pasta after 4 pm. If you visit there before, you will miss the best delicious pasta from Toffino. They offer meat ravioli, cheese ravioli, chicken parmigiana pasta. Depending on the ingredients you like, the price usually ranges between $10 and $25.

KIDS MENU

Kids will have a lot of fun here. They can build their slice of Pizza or order pasta, grilled cheese, or chicken tenders from Toffino’s Pizza.

AJ’S Pizza Myrtle Beach

Location: 5917 N Kings Hwy, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577

Open Hours: 11 am to 10 pm, Sunday and Monday closed

Contact Information: (843) 449-4600

Price: $10 to $25 per person

Visit AJ’s Pizza website for more information.

Different type of aj's pizza menu
Image Different AJs Pizza Source AJs Pizza

AJ”S pizza offers specialty pizzas, build your own pizza, appetizers, focaccia, wraps, salads and pasta.

Pizza

You can order small, medium, or large Pizza. Small Pizza prices start at $9.99, medium Pizza prices start at $15.49, and large Pizza prices start at $18.49. They have veggie Pizza, meat Pizza, chicken Pizza, cheese Pizza, sweet Thai, Taco Pizza, and many others.
I tried “Apple Grande” Pizza from AJ’s. This Pizza was made of apple butter, sliced apples with cinnamon, and brown sugar. This Pizza taste is so delicious. You can get this Pizza in small to large sizes.

Appetizers

You can get a taste of chicken wings, garlic bread sticks, flatbread, and boneless wings from AJ’s. The price is also very reasonable. Let’s look at the price-

Chicken or beef flatbread- $9.99

Chicken Wings- $14.49

Garlic Bread sticks- $5.99

Chicken Spring Rolls- $9.99

Boneless Wings- $12.99

Focaccia and Subs

They have all kinds of subs, such as club sandwiches, buffalo chicken subs, meatball subs, turkey and Swiss sandwiches, and roast beef. The price usually varies from $10.99 to $11.99.

Wrap

Aj’s has chicken Caesar wraps, buffalo chicken wraps, turkey wraps, and chicken pesto wraps. You can order any wrap for $10. I tried the chicken wrap, and I love chicken wraps. It is made of buffalo chicken, lettuce, red onion, cheddar, and ranch dressing. The taste was so delicious.

Salads and Pasta

For paste, you must spend $12.99 to $13.99 at AJ’s Pizza. You can try any pasta, like meat, veggies, or whatever you like. Also, the salad price is so reasonable. The price range varies from $7.99 to $10.99.

Capriccio

Location:  1285 38th Ave N, Myrtle Beach, SC 29577

Open Hours: 11.30 am to 9 pm

Contact Information: (843) 445-7100

Visit Capriccio website for more information.

Pasta on the table
Image Pasta at Capriccio Source Capriccio Pizza

Capriccio offers antipasto, soups, salads, pizza, baked dishes, sandwiches, kids’ menu and desserts.

Pizza

You can taste small to large Pizzas from Capriccio. Price varies from $9.95 to $16.99. If you would like more toppings for your Pizza, you must spend $1.50 for each topping.


Capriccio also provides special Pizza in large and personal sizes. Below, I give a detailed list of Capriccio Pizza prices and ingredients. Let’s check it out

Pizza TypePersonal Pizza PriceLarge Pizza PriceIngredients
Capriccio special$15.95$24.95Topped with tomatoes, spinach, grilled chicken & garlic.
Margherita$13.95$21.95sliced tomatoes, mozzarella, basil, garlic & olive oil
White $13.95$21.95virgin olive oil, ricotta,                     
mozzarella & Romano cheeses
Meat Lovers$14.95$22.95Sausage, pepperoni,
 meatballs & ham
Vegetarian$13.95$21.95broccoli, spinach, peppers, mushrooms, onions & garlic.

Pasta

All types of pasta are available here. But the price varies depending on which time you will go there. If you go to lunchtime, you have to pay $12.99 to $25.99 depending on which pasta you order, and at dinnertime; price varies from $16.95 to $25.99. So, dinner is usually almost $4 to $5 more than lunchtime.

Sandwiches

All sandwiches are served with Italian bread and fries. They offer chicken parmigiana, grilled chicken, eggplant parmigiana, meatballs, sausage, and peppers. The price varies from $11.95 to $20.99.

Kids Menu

For kids, Capriccio offers mozzarella sticks for $4.95, meatballs for $8.95, chicken tenders with fries for $7.95, and ravioli for $7.95. When I was there, I saw a lot of kids eating and playing with other kids.

Desserts

Capriccio offers different desserts. They offer Tartuffo for $8.50, cannoli for $7, and lemon cake for $7.

Conclusion

Some tourist areas do everything just right, and Myrtle Beach might be one of those places. Every year, tourists are coming here. They require assistance in determining where to go and what are the best places for breakfast, lunch or dinner. In this article, I tried to include the best Pizza places in Myrtle Beach. Although Myrtle Beach is a small city, it has a lot to offer in the way of cultural foods. You will have a number of Italy restaurants at Myrtle Beach for those who are Italian or love Italian food. You can also taste different types of other delicious foods at varying restaurants according to your preferences. Have a great meal, at Myrtle Beach!

author avatar
touringdiaryadventure.com

Touring Diary Adventure – Your ultimate guide to unforgettable travel experiences. Explore breathtaking destinations, insider tips, and travel inspiration to fuel your next adventure. Start your journey with us today!

Subscribe Now

Stay with us for getting more wonderful travel tips and news from my blog.

Copyright © 2025 Touring Diary Adventure